Employment Law Bulletin
November 2005

In This Issue:
 •  Welcome
 •  Disability law change
 •  Equal pay ruling
 •  Holiday pay
 •  Smoke-free Scotland
 •  New from Acas
 •  Training shortfall
 •  Safety statistics


Featured Links:
 •  Visit [name deleted] website
 •  Subscribe to these bulletins
 •  Acas website
Welcome
Preparing for age discrimination laws continues to be the subject currently causing businesses the most concern.

Consultation on the draft age discrimination legislation closed on 17 October, with 350 responses received at that point. The DTI tells us that these responses will now be analysed, with the aim of publishing the results “early in 2006” and incorporating any changes before laying the revised regulations before Parliament “around the turn of the year”.

This is to enable Parliament “to approve them as soon as possible, at least six months before they come into force”, which is expected to be on 1 October 2006, although we are hearing rumours that it may be put back to 1 December 2006 to give employers a little extra time to prepare. We will continue to keep you informed.

[Solicitor contact details deleted]


Disability law change
From 5 December, anybody suffering from cancer, multiple sclerosis or HIV will be deemed to have a ‘disability’ and therefore be entitled to the protection of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995.

A further change makes it easier for people suffering from mental illness to fall within the definition of ‘disabled’. Before 5 December, a mental illness had to be ‘clinically well recognised’ in order to qualify. From 5 December, that requirement is removed.

One of the main effects is that employers will be under a duty to make reasonable adjustments for those suffering from these conditions, when previously they may not have had to. Such adjustments will include allowing the employees to change to flexible working patterns in order to accommodate medical treatment.


Equal pay ruling
The Employment Appeal Tribunal has decided that the equal pay “genuine material defence” requires objective justification.

This is a departure from the traditional UK approach requiring an employer simply to be able to account for a pay difference by referring to a factor that is material but is not the employee's gender — unless the factor is itself one which may discriminate against female employees, in which case it must be objectively justified.

Instead, in Sharp v Caledonia Group Services Ltd, the Employment Appeal Tribunal has relied on the 2001 European Court of Justice authority of Brunhoffer v Bank Der Osterrichischen Postparkasse AG requiring objective justification, choosing not to follow its own decision last year in Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration v Fernandez, which held that a genuine material factor not related to sex was sufficient.

This ruling makes it much harder for employers to justify differences in pay, particularly in ‘red circling’ cases. However, permission has been given for the employer to appeal to the Court of Appeal, so the decision may end up being overturned in the next twelve months.


Holiday pay
Earlier this year, we reported that that the Court of Appeal had decided that employees on long-term sick did not continue to accrue the right to four weeks’ paid holiday each year.

The House of Lords has just given permission to appeal that decision. This means that the issue — thought by employers to have been resolved — remains uncertain for the time being.


Smoke-free Scotland
As you will know, a ban on smoking in the majority of public places comes into force from 26 March 2006.

The Scottish Executive has produced a set of PDFs, including approved guidance, the essentials of a “smoke-free policy”, information for bar staff, and “no smoking” signs in a variety of designs. Details from http://www.clearingtheairscotland.com/faqs/guidance.html


New from Acas
The Acas Model Workplace has been unveiled, offering a “one-stop” guide identifying the features of an organisation where people are managed effectively. The booklet will be priced at £4.95 but for the next three months will be available free for single copies and at £1.95 for two or more. Copies can be ordered via the website, by calling 08702 429090, or by emailing acas@eclogistics.co.uk.

Among other recent additions to the Acas website are:
  • the Acas Recognition Report, the findings (in PDF form) of a study which investigates the role and impact of Acas in the trade union recognition process following the introduction of Schedule A1 of the Employment Relations Act 1999. Nine case studies are used, including interviews with employers and union officers, as well as Acas conciliators.

  • a new, free online learning course to help understand and prevent workplace bullying, with topics including definitions of bullying and harassment, recognition and prevention, and the consequences of inaction. This is seventh such online course, which requires initial user registration.

  • an updated version of its 56-page PDF Religion or Belief in the Workplace – guidance to Employment Equality (Religion or Belief) Regulations 2003.

  • updated website guidance on flexible working.
Details of all these available from http://www.acas.org.uk


Training shortfall
A third of businesses never offer any training to their staff and 39 per cent of the UK workforce received no training last year, according to a TUC report.

The report — Training, Who Gets It? — found those in semi-skilled and manual jobs were the least likely to get training: while 60 per cent of employers had offered some form of training to professional staff in the past year, only 45 per cent had made the same offer to manual workers.

The 41-page PDF can be downloaded from http://www.tuc.org.uk/skills/tuc-10947-f0.cfm


Safety statistics
Latest key figures from the Health and Safety Executive for 2004-05 show that:
  • 220 workers were killed, a rate of 0.7 per 100,000 workers

  • 361 members of the public were fatally injured

  • 150,559 non-fatal injuries to workers were reported (a rate of 587 per 100,000 workers)

  • 2 million people suffered from an illness they considered was caused or worsened by current or past employment

  • 35 million working days were lost overall (1.5 per worker), 28 million due to work-related ill-health and 7 million due to workplace injury.
Full details in PDF form from http://www.hse.gov.uk/statistics/overpic.htm


[Solicitor's blurb and contact details deleted]


DISCLAIMER:

The information and any commentary contained in these bulletins is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or any other type of professional advice. [Name of firm deleted] do not accept and, to the extent permitted by law, exclude liability to any person for any loss which may arise from relying upon or otherwise using the information contained in these bulletins.

If you have a particular query or issue you are strongly advised to obtain specific, personal advice about your case or matter and not to rely on the information or comments in this bulletin.